
Took in a showing of U23D at Bayer’s Lake yesterday.
I’ve got U2’s last three concert videos, “Elevation Tour 2001 — Live from Boston”, “U2 Go Home” and “Vertigo//2005″, and frankly they’re all underwhelming. Sure, the production values are excellent, but the performances aren’t up to snuff. Not awful, either, just not up to U2’s abilities. Tantalizingly, the 2001 show was apparently shot the night after one of their best shows ever. So it goes. None of them come close to what I’ve long considered their best live video, the ZooTV Outside Broadcast from Sydney, Australia, in 1993.
U23D, however, wasn’t just a put-you-onstage-with-the-band film, it was a fully-engaging, immersive experience that documented a first-rate performance by one of the best bands on the planet. They were excellent.
I’ve been underwhelmed by IMAX in the past (bigger may be better, but that’s not enough to rescue a poor film like Titanica), but the 3D aspect was very well done. Of course there were some gratuitous guitar-necks-into-the-camera shots, but mostly it was about placing the viewer in the audience, on the stage. It wasn’t distracting; it added greatly to the film.
Something that seems obvious now that I hadn’t expected was 3D transitions. We’re all very used to seeing one shot dissolved into another, but having the first shot occupy space “close” to you, and the second “further” from you is surprisingly different. There’s a whole new cinematic language waiting to be discovered here.